Tuesday, March 31, 2009

Religion = Need

Though there are many varying explanations for Prehistoric cave painting, as is clear in the chapter: Palaeolithic art and religion, the one feature that unifies them all is the actual content of the paintings themselves. One can try to explain the different modes by which they were painted or what they represented, but it is impossible to dispute that the majority of the paintings were of animals. This may seem like a very obvious statement but when broken down and compared to other times and cultures, there may be more than meets the eye (or ear, i guess).
When asking the question "why paint animals?" many of the old/rejected theories cited in this chapter provide glimpses of an answer. For example, the "sympathetic magic" theory argues that painting an animal was a way to control it and thus help hunting (Clottes & Lewis-Williams 25), and the "totem" theory argues a hierarchical structure between humans and animals (Cottes & Lewis-Williams 27). What is common-ground between both of these, as well as the new ideas presented in this chapter, is the idea of a relationship between animal and man. This relationship is one of survival--man needs food. When so much importance and necessity is placed on one thing it in turn becomes the principal focus of life. This gives great power to the idea of the animal, as it is the provider for the main element prehistoric people needed.
Turning the clocks ahead we see similar trends on the relationship between need and religion. As basic needs--food, water, shelter--become more of a given, the "needs" of mankind were able to change. Because daily activity is not now consumed by hunting and finding water, other, arguably less essential, aspects of life have become "needs". Such needs may include: hope, happiness (or the promise of happiness), motivation, and companionship. These needs are some of fundamental pillars of modern religion and are clearly the most marketed for recruitment. 
What we can draw from this is the idea the we find meaning and significance in what is essential to our lives. Prehistoric man needed food and coincidentally (or not) he drew animals on the wall, modern man needs happiness and thus he goes to church where the components of happiness are promised. 


No comments:

Post a Comment